PS5 vs Xbox: Which Breaks Down More in Barrie?

Table Of Contents

Share:

Let’s settle something that gamers argue about harder than pineapple on pizza:

Which console breaks more — PS5 or Xbox?

We’re not talking about performance, exclusives, or whose controller feels better in adult-sized hands. We’re talking cold, hard reality. The part no one wants to brag about:

Repair stats. Failures. Breakdowns. The stuff you call us for when things go sideways.

And since we run a game console repair shop here in Barrie, we’ve got a front-row seat to who’s really holding it together — and who’s getting hauled in for emergency HDMI surgery.

First Things First: Yes, They Both Break

Let’s be clear: both Sony and Microsoft made powerful, fast, sleek consoles.

But also? They both have weak spots. Fragile ports. Cooling quirks. Chips that don’t like power spikes. And all the stress of daily use, accidental tugs, and the occasional toddler attack.

So this isn’t about console shaming — it’s about what we see in the wild. Real repairs from real gamers in Barrie.

So… Which Breaks More?

Based on our past 100+ game console repairs here at OneUpFix, here’s the breakdown:

  • PS5: 78% of total repairs
  • Xbox Series X/S: 12% of total repairs

PS5 edges out Xbox in breakdown frequency — but this is likely because the PS5 sold many more units then the Xbox.

What Breaks Most Often on the PS5?

  1. HDMI Port (by a mile)
    The most common PS5 issue we see. Fragile as glass. If someone sneezes near it while the HDMI cable is in, it might bend a pin.
  2. Overheating / Fan Noise
    PS5s can run hot, especially if the fan’s full of dust or thermal paste is failing.
  3. Power issues
    Rare, but when they happen, they’re usually bad — retimer chips, filters, or power rails fried.

And What About the Xbox?

  1. HDMI Port
    Same issue — different layout. Xbox ports are just as delicate, maybe more so due to being recessed and rigid.
  2. No Power
    More common on Xbox than PS5. Bad filters, blown caps, or cooked chips after power surges.
  3. Fan Clatter / Coil Whine
    Not a hardware failure, but enough people ask us about it that we started keeping replacement fans on hand.

Which Console Costs More to Fix?

It depends on the repair.

  • HDMI port replacement: the same, $199 for both
  • Power issues: Xbox tends to cost a bit more if the power chip is toast
  • Fan replacement / cleaning: PS5 is slightly more involved due to size and internal layout

In general: expect similar pricing. But the PS5 often wins the award for “most dramatic failure.”

Which Console Is Built Better?

Honestly? It’s close.

  • The PS5 is engineered like a spaceship — sleek, powerful, but not the easiest to take apart or reassemble.
  • The Xbox Series X is a tank. Boxy, boring, but well-designed thermally and easier to work on. The Series S is the most fragile of the three, though — cheaper build, easier to overheat.

If you’re looking for repairability, Xbox gets a slight edge.
If you’re looking for high failure drama (like HDMI ports torn out with part of the board), PS5 wins.

Our Personal Take

We’re not loyal to either side. We’ve seen them both at their worst — mid-repair, mid-meltdown, and mid-explaining-to-parents-why-it’s-$199.

But if we had to choose:

  • PS5: More powerful, more likely to break if you look at it wrong.
  • Xbox: Less sexy, more stable. Still breaks, just not as dramatically.

TL;DR

  • Both consoles are great… until they’re not.
  • PS5 breaks more often, mostly HDMI-related.
  • Xbox has more power issues.
  • Repairs cost about the same.
  • Neither is indestructible.
  • Don’t let kids yank HDMI cables out like they’re starting a lawnmower.

Need Yours Fixed?

Whether it’s a dead port, fried chip, or just a weird noise that makes you nervous — we fix all of it right here in Barrie.

Real repairs. Fast turnaround. Honest pricing.
No sending it to a warehouse in the middle of nowhere.

Book your Xbox repair
Or see our PS5 repair page

Related Posts You Might Like

Related Posts